Business Information Edit info
Restaurants, PizzaRestaurants, Notable Beer List, $, Pizza, Group Dining, Visa, MasterCard
Top Sentiments among Old Chicago Reviewers
Love dish Chicago style pizza
Yummy homestyle pizza
Fresh mushroom pizza
Delicious deep dish style pizza
Better wine list
Airy garlic bread
Love Old Chicago Pizza
Great flavor
Wonderful double crust pizza
Fresh garlic sprinkled
Customer Reviews (11)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 14, 2008This is hands down the best pizza in Sonoma county! If you are in hurry this is not the place to go, as it takes time to make these pizza's but it is well worth the wait. The staff is great, the place is cozy and fun. I also love ... (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch Jun 22, 2008In Short
This neighborly pizza-and-subs restaurant is a sports lovers' haven, with its plasma TVs, numerous beer signs and Chicago sports team paraphernalia. But the casual, tavern-like vibe also ... (more)
FattyFaux
on Citysearch Mar 29, 2008First I am not just this overweight guy with a faux hawk at Old Chicago, I am THE overweight guy with a faux hawk at Old Chicago. For every little "Couldn?t" on the internet who cries, know I'm turning over 15-25 tables a ... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Mar 03, 2008If you like pizza, then you definitely have to go here. They have be best deep dish pizza I have ever had. This may not be the best place for a low calorie meal, but if you are ever looking for a really good pizza, try this ... (more)
couldnt
on Citysearch Jan 01, 2008Now, before I get too far into this review and forget to mention this... I only gave this four stars because it is the only place you can get Chicago Pizza North of San Francisco (especially since Uno's mysteriously ... (more)
tamalpaisdream
on Citysearch Oct 23, 2007It is mouthwatering good! If thick crust is your thing, this is the place. The dough and their delicious ingredients are seriously good! (more)
wallstpup
on Citysearch Jan 12, 2006If they had got the dough right ,they would have earned a highly recommended. I ordered the combo deep dish, $26. The meld of flavors - the sauce, cheese, toppings was just fabulous. This is what pizza needs to taste ... (more)
scttourguide
on Citysearch Nov 10, 2005This is the kind of pizza joint the gang from the TV Show "Cheers" would hang out at. Fabulously thick pizza loaded with cheese and dough that melts on your tongue coupled with a cozy & unpretentious setting. Sure the ... (more)
2big
on Citysearch Jul 30, 2005Over the years, we've eaten here several times. The pizza is deep dish and very good.The crust is thick but not doughy. The toppings are quality and flavorful. Seating is cramped and being as how the building is old and ... (more)
smsteffy
on Citysearch May 04, 2005Terrific pizza. Long wait but ssooooo worth it! By far the best pizzas I've ever had, also very consistent. (more)
